A LOVE SCENE
AND
ITS ANATOMY


  If you've ever watched a movie or television scene in which the camera zooms in, time is drawn down into slow motion, some important action takes place, and then time returns to to normal speed as the camera zooms back out again, you'll understand what's happening when things become intimate between the two main characters in Desert Hearts. The love scene here is not just a portion of the film during which a sexual encounter takes place. It's a full, genuine exploration of a piece of the story that is as beautifully told as any other part, and during which detail is brought close up, with time passing in increments that make it possible to carefully follow each moment as it unfolds.

  While it begins with a jolt, followed by an additional nudge, the rest of the love scene in Desert Hearts is very gentle and sweet. However, there's no less tension in it for that. It's filled with anxious anticipation. Vivian Bell has spent the entire 35 years of her life prior completely buried in the closet and shut off from most of the rest of her emotional being by a combination of determination and decorum. Now she struggles between her fear of letting go and her need to be passionate and open with someone she can love and trust. Cay Rivvers, who is 25, knows what she's doing, and is on the verge of finally getting the woman she feels she's been waiting for all her life, has to find a way to mix her own eagerness and drive with that right combination of moving things forward and allowing Vivian a chance to catch up that will keep the whole thing from being derailed. It's thrilling.

  In fact, there's enough tension for there to be room for a little humor at the beginning, to break it up a bit. You could say things start off a bit awkwardly in Vivian's hotel room, as she finds that what she thought was only going to be a conversation has suddenly become a confrontation of sorts. Vivian has been caught off guard to begin with, passing the time in her fuzzy, pink bathrobe, not having tidied her hair in her customary fashion. Cay's visit with her is uninvited and unexpected. Cay's behavior, and the reaction others have had to the little they knew (and much they assumed) about it, has unnerved Vivian enough already. By this point, nothing more has happened between them physically than a kiss in the rain, some days earlier, which Vivian thinks she would very much like to be able to dismiss. But Cay has insisted that Vivian let her in to talk about it. And Vivian, though completely unprepared, has made every effort to take some sort of high ground. In a moment of exasperation, Vivian steps around a corner for about half a minute, to pour herself a drink. She then turns back to discover Cay is completely naked, sitting in her bed. This situation isn't going to just go away. And now she's also having to face the fact that she doesn't necessarily want it to. Some of everybody's favorite lines of dialogue from the film follow:

Vivian: "I wouldn't know what to do."
Cay: "You can start by putting the 'Do Not Disturb' sign on the door."

Which she does, afterwards returning to stand a short distance from the bed, awkwardly looking away.

Vivian: "Well, that part went smoothly."
Cay: "So, take your hands out of your pockets and come here."

Which she does, making her way over to sit on the bed, awkwardly waiting to find out what happens next.

Vivian: "I'm not taking off my robe."
Cay: "Well, everybody draws the line somewhere."

  And so, with that endearing little exchange, the tone is set for everything that follows to be honest and sweet, because they begin with this simple way of Cay letting Vivian know things will be all right.

  That doesn't mean, though, that the rest is suddenly easy for Vivian. Cay has to take the lead, as Vivian tries to figure out how to let herself respond. Cay, as it turns out, is a very attentive and patient lover. She draws Vivian in but doesn't trap her. Vivian is hesitant and uncertain. You can imagine her heart pounding as though she were teetering on the edge of a cliff, both fearful of falling and yet somehow still wanting to. She almost seems to step off a couple of times, but not quite. All the while, Cay's sensitivity and the easy pace she sets serve as ready reassurance.

  It isn't too long before Vivian discovers she's not quite so committed to that robe of hers as she'd thought. But she still holds herself back, needing to pause a couple of times to collect herself - right up until Cay has moved things far enough along that Vivian seems to have arrived at some kind of limit to what she can handle. We can assume, though we don't actually see it, that things have now moved below the waist, and there's no pretending this is just some delicately sexy cuddling any more. This is probably as vulnerable as Vivian has ever felt in her life. And she could hardly be more exposed right then than to be in the full, close-up view of another woman who's in direct contact, making her feel sensations she's never felt before. Vivian's composure flags enough when Cay moves back up to look into her eyes that Vivian, in brief embarrassment, tries to hide her face a little behind her hand. But this may actually be the best thing that could've happened. In quickly recovering herself and deciding to apologize for almost shutting Cay out, Vivian finally discovers she's able let go of her need to shield herself from what's happening. For the first time, she now really looks into Cay's eyes. This is her turning point from telling herself, "Okay, maybe I can allow this to go on and see what happens," to, "I want this." From here on, she more actively takes part, even rolling Cay over so that Vivian no longer lies passively underneath.

  When Cay turns over, we catch a glimpse of a beautiful little smile on her face, as she realizes she's finally getting the woman she loves - not just her reluctant consent and her unsteadily compliant body, but her fully willing heart and at last unlocked sensuality. After so many pent up years, it seems to take very little, by then, for Vivian to tip over the edge. And when she does, she discovers she isn't lost or hurt by falling. Rather than the long drop and painful impact she might have expected, she finds a much shorter distance than she could ever have imagined between where she once stood in fear and the soft, comforting embrace into which she's now landed. In the pause that follows, the way Cay touches Vivian seems to convey her understanding of Vivian's feelings. They then continue to make love, with the fade to black that ends the scene slow enough for the glow of the moment to really satisfyingly linger.

  Insightful and revealing, tenderly played out, quietly erotic - the artistry of this scene stands apart from those of other films. That it's called a classic is not just a fine compliment. It's an honor it richly deserves.



  Lasting a little over ten minutes, Anatomy of a Love Scene is a special feature from Disk 2 of the Desert Hearts Vintage Collection DVD set that illuminates how the love scene from Desert Hearts was filmed. You'll find it at the top of the menu, listed as "Extended Love Scene". With only about eight people immediately involved, two of them acting in the scene, and two of them not actually right there in the room during the process, the scene was created in a small, intimate setting - with more necessary than just the two we see, of course, but certainly not a crowd. The whole thing is preceded with a screen of text explaining why this feature was included, what it's made from, and who was present for the filming. The next screen of text sets the tone for audience expectations... and away we go!

  Right at the outset, we have a chance to see an important part of what this is all about: multiple takes and varied camera angles. Before anything more cozy begins, we see Helen Shaver, as Vivian Bell, delivering the same line of dialogue five separate times, as captured from five different angles. If you've watched the film, you'll recognize the one that ended up being used and see why it was preferred.

  Much of what you'll find in this feature doesn't appear in the film at all. There were some moments (and even a small piece of dialogue) that just weren't going to fit when the whole thing was edited together. So, it's an extra little treat to see more happening between the characters than just what made it into the finished product. If you enjoy the way these two women kiss and touch, you won't be disappointed. But when you consider the flow of the finished scene, you'll understand why there wasn't more of it there.

  One of the best aspects of this feature, however, is the stuff that was never meant to be part of the film. The love scene is gentle and sweet. Anatomy of a Love Scene is sweeter. It gives us a peek into the kind of circumstances that made it possible for the love scene to be what it was. We can hear the voices of the various people involved, all of them speaking relatively softly. Instead of the feeling of risk and tension the love scene was designed to convey, here we find a strong sense of security and a relaxed environment.

  But what's really a delight is the way the two leading ladies interact with each other in between takes. Their trust in each other is clear. And we can clearly see why, as they smile and chuckle over little things while they wait for the camera to roll again. This is more like life, as anyone who has giggled with a lover in bed knows; and so it's easy to understand how these two women (both married to men for many years, now) were able to carry off the perception of being true lovers so convincingly. Patricia Charbonneau, playing Cay Rivvers, is especially tender and sweet in the way she talks to her costar. She calls her "toots", and she calls her "baby", all the while cradling her reassuringly in her arms. As near as I can tell, with apologies for any errors on my part, here are a couple of the things she says to her:

When it's time for Ms. Shaver, in her pink bathrobe, to lean back in Ms. Charbonneau's arms, she says,
"Get comfortable... I'll hold you... Get comfortable. Let's let you feel good. It's your close-up, toots."

And later, as they lie naked together, Ms. Charbonneau looking down at Ms. Shaver, she tells her,
"It's not my bad side. As far as hair goes, there's no need to go into this, baby."

  It's the most lovely, charming "shop talk" you ever heard. What a pleasure to know how genuinely warm they were with each other as they went about generating the heat that was so pleasurable in the film. What's plain is that they didn't just have some kind of mysterious initial chemistry that made it good for them to be cast together. They obviously had ongoing chemistry, largely because they were really able to connect, respect each other, make each other feel safe, and have a good time together. They cared very much about the story, about their work, and about each other. And it shows.

  Director Donna Dietch made the wise choice of shooting the love scene on the 30th of 31 days of filming, so that her cast and crew could have a chance to get to know each other. And she made sure to do everything she could so that everyone involved felt they would be treated appropriately. She saw to it that they knew any concerns they might have could be expressed and would really be heard and dealt with. There's no way to miss the effect of all her preparations. By the time they all got into that room together, it seems each person's mindset was geared towards keeping everybody, and especially the two stars, feeling good about what was going on. And those two certainly seemed to take very good care of each other. The result is a beautiful display of love between women that has captivated audiences ever since it was first shown on the big screen and that has since become the stuff of legend.



Preview of the DVD Extra, "Anatomy of a Love Scene",
a special feature on disc 2 of the Collector's Edition of Desert Hearts,
presented on YouTube by Wolfe Video.



The Desert Hearts section of my Website is in no way officially associated with the film,
the book upon which it was based, or anyone involved in the making or distribution thereof.
It exists for the sole purpose of providing an outlet for my own personal writing about the book and film,
two beautiful works I encourage you to dicsover and enjoy for yourself.

Thanks for visiting!
Back to the Articles Menu


Click on the envelope to go to the Mailbox.

Wayshelter E-Mail



All contents ©

The Wayshelter

Copyright Dates

unless otherwise noted.